APAGear II Archives Volume 2, Number 1 February, 2000

APAGear II

Critique Assignments

Who Should Critique Whom

Here it is, folks. Use this list to determine whom you should critique for this issue. Briefly, the purpose of assigning reviews to the APAGear members is to ensure that each member has the chance to receive feedback. You can choose to review additional articles, of course, but this list is the bare minimum.

Critique List

Great Thor's Ghost! By the Prophet! In the name of Masao! Can it be true? Actual critique assignments?!? Yes! Since this issue had an assignment (a theme), one area you might want to critique is the author's implementation of the theme. (Keep in mind, though, that it's not automatically a bad thing if an author didn't follow the theme.) Not only was there a theme this issue, the authors were instructed to write in the first person. You might want to contemplate how well the author carried out the first person style, as well.

  Scott
Blow
Jason
English
John
Guilfoyle
Janne
Kemppi
Buji
Kern
Tom
McGrenery
Josh
Peters
Scott Blow   X X X X    
Candy Man     X X X X  
Wayne Chang       X X X X
Bernard David X       X X X
Jason English X   X     X X
Alistair Gillies X X X       X
John Guilfoyle X X   X X    
Kevin Hinote   X X X X    
Rick Horton     X X X X  
Janne Kemppi X       X X X
Buji Kern X X       X X
Tom McGrenery X X X       X
Josh Peters X X   X   X  
Christian Schaller   X X X     X

If there's an "X" in a column for the row with your name, then you should critique that member's contribution.

Back to APAGear II Archives


APAGear II Archives Volume 2, Number 1 February, 2000